Sharing Voices – Part II

Interviews about rights of women in Egypt – Hopes and Aspirations

Nadia

Nadia Siraj – Interviewee

Following the previous post about Maryam few weeks ago here is my II part of the series. 

Nadia Siraj (44, Cairo) was born in Saudi Arabia. She has lived half of her life in Saudi Arabia and half in Egypt. She has worked as Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) expert for corporations such as the National Commercial Bank in Jada, Microsoft, British Consulate or Islamic Development Bank as well as in the Social Field in several countries such as Saudi Arabia, Egypt or Dubai. At some point, she decided to leave corporate and focus more on Meditation and Energy, which had always been her passion. She believes in the importance of empowering people regardless of any condition, thereby making people being themselves. Nadia loves self-expression through body (dancing and music). She is co-founder of a centre that promotes meditation through dancing in order to make people to find their own serenity.

Maryam and Nadia stories make you clearly see some aspects that negatively affect women. In their opinion, the increasing influence of wrong religious interpretations, tradition and even Capitalism (‘is the other extreme of treating a woman like an object and making her feel she is unworthy without having certain looks, buying certain products, etc.’) make women to be more exposed to harassment, to be forced to wear veil, to get married at certain age or being restricted of choices and submissive on relationships. This process has especially been strengthen since late 70’s, ‘when wahabi culture started being imported to Egypt’.

Nevertheless, Maryam and Nadia believe ‘women are awaking’. Women are becoming conscious about their situation. Rather, as Nadia notices, there is raising ‘a strong reaction reflected by feminism movements’, although, in her opinion, another positive respond to fight for equality could have been developed instead of a movement based on ‘frustration and opposition’.

Since the fall of Mubarak’s regime (February 2011), Nadia believes that the ‘revolution’ worked for something and the fall of Mubarak’s regime ‘broke something old’ so it triggered a process ‘in which people realize that there are other options in life’.

On the other hand Nadia  considers that ‘ her divorce was one of the big turning points in her life because she realized that all people, who interfered in her life and were so keen on finding ways to control her. They are not there anymore or they are only there when it requires control. She said, she started questioning many of the values and beliefs in which she had been raised and then she disregarded many of them without being reactive, because being reactive will make things worse’. She is instilling it to her son and her parents start ‘to see things differently when it comes to raising girls different from boys and controlling them more than boys. ‘It’s a learning process for all of us we are breaking cycles of unnecessary controlling and being controlled’ she said.

Nadia highlights her younger period in Saudi Arabia, where it was very difficult for a woman to have a job. More recently, she remembers the harsh period she spent because of her son’s custody: ‘I have suffered dealing with separation, and the law stands always on the side of the man more than a woman’ For Nadia it was even difficult to being with being divorced with a son.

Hence, when I asked Nadia about the role of men in women’s situation, she said: ‘there were successful women who were supported by their fathers, their husbands, their brothers, etc. I was lucky to be one of them in certain aspects of my life where my father was there to give me support. Nevertheless, it is not the case anymore because there is much competition and people are so busy with their own stories so a lot of women have to empower themselves by finding their ways’.

Talking about younger women Maryam and Nadia agree on the fact that there is a certain polarity or contrast, but at different levels. Nadia observed that new generations face ‘resistance from the elders, who cannot accept that the whole area of security (everything that they believe in and keeps them alive) is being shacked. They don’t want that. They want to hold on to what they know and believe, so the younger generations are challenging the older ones and only those of them (the young ones) who get stuck in the ego and self-victimization are not able to move on and adopt change’.

Thus, looking at the future like Maryam, Nadia has a lot of hope. She sees ‘more respect from young men and they are more in touch with their feminine side; whereas many women are standing for themselves, for their rights and being more confident’. However, she points out the way Middle East societies are viewed, especially from Western countries. First, ‘they are always focused on books and conferences. It is always focused on driving, entrepreneurs, etc. and it is not focused more on based wise on women’s need. Whatever they look at, it is more in favour of consumerism at the end; so entities that promote independence in these aspects make women independent only financially, thereby making more consumers as equal as men’. Thus, she doesn’t see this independence ‘as a genuine step in really being concern on women’. Secondly, she saw many women from different countries (Dubai, Morocco, UK, Iran, Turkey, US) who had their own issues. They ‘are not equally treated as men, not equally paid as men, emotionally or physically abused by men’. Hence, she doesn’t like the idea of ‘spotlighting Middle East as an area where women are oppressed and it doesn’t happen anywhere else’.

She told me that ‘it is happening everywhere in different ways’.

Javier Javier Milán López (27, Spain) graduated in Political Science and Public Administration and specialized in International Cooperation, Project Management and Development Processes. He has been involved in activist movements as well as getting involved into Social Field through volunteering. He has worked for NGOs at national and international level (Spain, Senegal and Egypt) as project manager assistant and consultant/facilitator. Currently, he is doing a European Volunteering Service in Romania. Milán López (27, Spain) graduated in Political Science and Public Administration and specialized in International Cooperation, Project Management and Development Processes. He has been involved in activist movements as well as getting involved into Social Field through volunteering. He has worked for NGOs at national and international level (Spain, Senegal and Egypt) as project manager assistant and consultant/facilitator. Currently, he is doing a European Volunteering Service in Romania.

 

Another blow of the machete to free speech and democracy in Bangladesh

9614160500_2d5664fded_z

By Ophelia Chatterjee

“No one should cross the limit” announced Bangladesh’s Inspector General of Police earlier this month. In the wake of the murder of Niloy Neel, the fourth secularist Bangladeshi blogger to be hacked to death this year, this may seem both an attempt to close the stable door on escalating fundamentalist violence after it has already bolted, and a wilful understatement given the horrific severity and increasing incidence of such attacks.

But astonishingly, the senior officer was not sanctioning the perpetrators of the attacks, but rather warning activists to censor themselves if they want to avoid being placed on one of several hit lists – the likes of which have already proven fatal for Neel and three others this year alone. This barely tacit official justification for fatally attacking and maiming people for expressing their views is a stark indication of both the source and scale of the problem currently being faced in Bangladesh. Global Minorities Alliance has joined hands with the International Humanist and Ethical Union, signing an open letter to the Bangladeshi Prime Minister and president calling on them to condemn this victim blaming narrative.

The government and constitution of the Muslim majority country are ostensibly secular, and have been since Bangladesh’s hard-won independence from Pakistan in 1971. However, activists such as Imran Sarker have accused those currently in power of channelling more energy into the hounding of secularists in the name of ‘defending Islam’, than reining in groups such as the militant Ansarullah Bangla Team who have claimed responsibility for the horrific attacks. This flaccid commitment to the protection of freedom of speech and democratic values has intensified in tandem with a sudden surge in attacks on secularist activists in the last two years. The 2010 establishment of a war crimes tribunal forced the country to grapple with its considerable lack of internal consensus over the role of religion in politics, and since 2013 eight bloggers have been violently attacked. Reports have emerged that prior to his murder Neel expressed his fear that he would be targeted to the police. According to Taslima Nasreen, the only assistance offered in response was the advice that he should leave the country. Contrast this with the prompt arrest of journalist Probir Sikdar just last week, who accused a cabinet minister of committing war crimes during the war for independence – it seems that the police are still on higher alert for the crime of “cast[ing] aspersion on a minister using information technology” than for taking action against those perpetuating the current bloodbath. Angry accusations that the government is pandering to hard-line elements within Bangladesh’s Muslim majority are becoming increasingly difficult to rebuff.

The roots of this recent escalation are complex, and heavily related to the Pandora’s box of carnage and instability clumsily unleashed by US and UK led intervention across neighbouring regions in recent decades. In a year in which Human Rights Watch has despairingly observed that “it can seem as if the world is unravelling”, these events form just a small part of the patchwork of instability, turmoil and bloodshed that has swept across the Middle East and parts of Asia and Africa.

The GMA Blog seemed a fitting place to discuss these appalling attempts to silence expression of dissident views online. These events have been a stark reminder that we are lucky to be living in a place and time where we have the luxury to be able to take protection from this for granted – however, we should not be complacent, and should continue to challenge attempts to undermine this right wherever they appear. This may be in the guise of the UK Conservative government’s more-than faintly sinister counter-extremism bill at home, or further afield. As many in Bangladesh are currently urging, it is not simply a case of whether the keyboard is mightier than the machete, but whether governments at home and around the world will begin to accord all their citizens the protections due to them, regardless of their political or religious affiliation.

Fringe Festival 2015: Scottish human rights organisation defends freedom of religion and expression

PRESS RELEASE FOR IMMEDIATE USE

Edinburgh: A Glasgow based human rights organisation, Global Minorities Alliance (GMA) was invited to participate in a discussion panel during the Edinburgh Fringe Festival 2015. The programme addressed the question “Are there limits when it comes to religion and free speech?” and was hosted by the Edinburgh Interfaith Association which promotes respect and understanding among all faiths in Edinburgh and across the world.

The event was organised as a response to the Charlie Hebdo tragedy in France earlier this year, to discuss and debate the global issues of religious freedom and free expression.

The panel consisted of Shahid Khan, a journalist from Pakistan, Fadel Soliman, an Imam from Egypt, and Thiago Alves Pinto, a legal expert from Brazil, who shared their thoughts about religion and freedom expression in the contemporary world.  Continue reading →