Germany’s welcome to migrants wears thin as Cologne launches more festivities

German CarnivalGermany is preparing for Carnival Festivities/Neuwiser, Flickr

by Claire de Galembert, ENS Cachan – Paris-Saclay

Willkommenskultur, or “culture of acceptance”, has been a major part of the German political discourse since summer 2015. It evokes a spirit of solidarity towards the large number of migrants who have sought asylum in the European Union over the past year.

This commitment, together with the work of many volunteers to supplement state support for new arrivals, seemed to finally lift the shadows of Germany’s past – and almost made the world forget that it had long refused to consider itself a country of migration. The generosity seemed all the more spectacular with many of its neighbours being less than welcoming to new arrivals.

But the Germany of 2016 has a Willkommenskultur hangover. The country is in shock after the events of New Year’s Eve in Cologne, a city that has long been a symbol of German multiculturalism. And now, as Cologne prepares for its annual carnival festivities, the city has doubled its police presence and increased video surveillance. A local girls’ school will close on the opening day of the carnival to protect its students.

This is unsurprising when we recall the events of New Year’s Eve in Cologne, at least those that seem proven: women who came to the centre to watch the festivities were attacked by groups of men under the influence of alcohol, some of the men were described as of “Arab or North African origin” and some of them were asylum seekers.

The extent of the crimes was either little noticed or little admitted by the police, who initially described the evening as relatively peaceful. This optimistic assessment was quickly refuted by the exponential increase in complaints. By January 18, the total number of alleged crimes stood at 766, nearly half of which were sexual in nature, including three rapes. The head of police was suspended over his handling of the attacks.

‘We can do it’?

Willkommenskutur portrayed citizens as being ready to roll up their sleeves and take on the social and economic costs of integration of newcomers – estimated to be €50 billion by 2017. But it was far from universally felt in Germany. The continuous flow of arrivals, the difficulty of housing and integrating more than a million refugees, and disagreements within the EU over sharing the burden stoked scepticism within society at large, and among mainstream political parties. Meanwhile, the Islamophobic movement Pegida launched attacks on immigrants, both on social media (including the #raperefugee Twitter hashtag) and in the streets.

At a December meeting of the ruling CDU party, Angela Merkel received a long standing ovation after her speech on the refugees crisis, reaffirming her leadership within the party. But this has not stemmed the tide of complaints. Her mantra “Schaffen wir das!” (“We can do it!”) seemed to many to be more of an incantation than an expression of collective will.

The Cologne attacks have weakened the moral consensus that had formed around the Chancellor. And they were a godsend to Merkel’s critics, including the right-wing Alternative für Deutschland party. The events of New Year’s Eve fit perfectly with their preferred themes, particularly the link they draw between refugees and security, not to mention the difficulty of assimilating immigrants and the threat to Germany’s gender-equality standards.

Populist rhetoric

Beyond the rise of xenophobic violence, evidence of a shift in German attitudes is widespread. A regional mayor in Bavaria sent a group of immigrants by bus to Berlin to protest Germany’s asylum laws. In an interview, none other than former chancellor Gerhard Schröder asserted that Europe’s doors couldn’t be left open forever:

The capacity to take in, care for and integrate refugees in Germany is limited, not unlimited. Anything else is an illusion.

The unease has been felt even more strongly in other European countries. Germany’s willingness to meet the challenge of mass immigration through its Willkommenskultur has been unbearable for its neighbours. Many seized on the situation as evidence that they were right all along about the need to close Europe’s borders – and to call into question Merkel’s unilateral choice to open them. The prime minister of Slovakia, Robert Fico, went so far as to say that “migrants cannot be integrated”.

Germany’s populist movements have their parallels elsewhere, from the National Front in France to Nigel Farage and UKIP in the UK and Republicans Donald Trump and Ted Cruz in the United States. After the attacks, Trump went to Twitter in an attempt to link immigration and insecurity:

Ethical responsibility

But beyond the populists and xenophobes, signs are everywhere of a more difficult political climate. Not just the closing of borders, but also a hardening of tone – for example, a proposed law in Denmark would authorise the confiscation of refugees’ valuables. It’s a safe bet that the spreading appeal of anti-immigrant attitudes, once limited to the extreme right, will harm immigrants already living in Europe, especially Muslims.

The erosion of Willkommenskultur means Germany must leave behind the moral stance underpinning Angela Merkel’s position and return to the ethic of responsibility, as laid out in the work of German sociologist and philosopher Max Weber. This requires consideration not only of the economic capacity for absorbing such an immense wave of immigrants but also its social and political acceptability. Failing to do so risks aggravating the panic emerging in Germany and beyond.

But the ethic of responsibility doesn’t obviate the need to come up with a balanced European response to immigration that remains true to the rule of law – otherwise, the populist rhetoric will continue to have a wide appeal. Between the pitfalls of being insufficiently attentive to the concerns of a growing percentage of the German population and giving in to the diktats of the extreme right, the way forward is a narrow one, but it exists.

The Conversation

Claire de Galembert, Sociologue CNRS, ENS Cachan – Paris-Saclay

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

The Victims of Pakistan’s Acid Attacks

Yesterday, The New York Times published an opinion article by Nicholas Kristof, which highlighted the plight of thousands of women in Pakistan who become victims of the acid attacks far and wide in the country. These poor women become the victims of patriarchy, societal norms as their lives, relationships, family and above all their ‘being’ is neglected, denied, deprived and even sacrificed on the name of ‘honour’.

Being a woman in a patriarchal society is an unimaginable life. You are reduced to nothingness. You do not hold any feelings, emotions or any respect. Your existence is no longer an existence. It’s something there, open to abuse, violence and sometimes murder. A life some argue, is worse than a death.

Global Minorities Alliance urges Pakistan government to implement laws with action to help thousands of women who become victims of this barbarous acts of violence by men. There is indeed no ‘honour’ in killing.

The ‘Saving Face’ a documentary which has highlighted the plight of these women who go through excruciating pain both at familial, societal and legal level to get justice. However, not everyone get justice. The fight for rights of women go on.

To watch the documentary on the acid victims of Pakistan click here: ‘Saving Face‘

Support Kenyan Slum School

Collage

Right to education is one of the most fundamental human rights. Education promotes individual freedom and empowerment. It has a life changing power which transforms us to be a productive part of the society. It is true to say that education is the mother of all rights. However, sadly enough, millions of children and adults are still deprived of this foundational right even in the 21st century. Global Minorities Alliance believes in the advancement of education as part of our fundamental purpose to fight persecution, injustices and inequalities, which we continue to promote at all levels.

In 2014, Global Minorities Alliance launched its #GMAGiftBox4Kids for Kenyan slum children in Kibera, Kenya, one of the largest urban slums in the world. We launched the campaign and with the help of our local partners in Glasgow we were able to send classroom materials (papers, pens, pencils, notepads, toys etc.) to primary school children in Kibera slum in Nairobi. We received the pictures of a thrilled children with wide smiles on their faces after they received our small donation.

Last year, GMA’s representative in Nairobi, Anne Misiko informed us with the need to build a primary library. It is hard to imagine a school without a library, or students without access to the books. We started a campaign and looked for local partners who could help us raise support. We collected close to 500 primary books to date with the Scotstoun Community Centre and Glasgow Cathedral. We are also thankful to Netherlee Primary School, Renfrewshire, Glasgow for their on-going support who even invited us to present the campaign to their school children. We are thankful to children and parents for their readiness and willingness to bring some hope and smile on these slum children in Kenya. We are also thankful for all those who are helping us spread the message on social media.

This month we launched our online donation page to raise funds to build a library. Once our target of £5000 is achieved GMA will provide books, tables, chairs, shelves and computer so children can access to the books when they need it.

You can help us promote the campaign on Facebook, Twitter and LinkedIn.

Also, you can be part of our fundraising team. Whether you are a student or businessman, please join hands with GMA and help empower these children with no books. If you can raise the individual gift of just £25 towards our Kenya library Project as an acknowledgement to your contribution, Global Minorities Alliance will send you the GMA Certificate for your participation in the project. Please drop us an email on info@globalminorities.co.uk before/after the donor sends the gift so we can identify the gift with your name. We can then post the certificate to your address. Thank you!

You can also invite a friend or a family member and can simply donate on this page:

#Books4Future – Help building a library in Kenya:  https://fundrazr.com/campaigns/f15lm9/ab/54brp6

GMA’s Charity Appeal Video: https://www.facebook.com/411533358921035/videos/963299467077752/

Providing a book to a child today can help change his/her life. It changed mine. It changed yours. Why not these slum children in Kibera?

Shahid Khan is the vice-chairperson of Global Minorities Alliance (www.globalminorities.co.uk) He tweets @shahidshabaz